Why Leaders Don’t Create More Leaders

Stacey Ashley Blog

Why Leaders Don’t Create More Leaders


I was 23 years old when I landed my first professional leadership role. I was the new Company Accountant, reporting to the CFO in a multinational manufacturing company, with my first team of eight people. A Bookkeeper, Accounts Payable and Receivables Clerks, Inventory Manager, Imports and Exports Clerk and Office Manager. I was pretty excited.

It was a fantastic opportunity. A leadership role. And I was reporting to someone who was a very experienced leader. I expected to learn a lot about leadership.

I was mistaken.

The second day in my new role was my birthday. My new boss, Barbara, asked me if I could start early that day as we had a lot to do. Sure, I said. And I was at work at 7am. I hustled all day, doing her bidding. I finished work at 9:30pm that night after doing tasks…no thinking…all day.

No birthday dinner for me!

It didn’t take me long to realise that Barbara viewed leadership as a cut throat competition and any competitors, in this case me, were a threat. The rules were simple. To win the competition you kept hold of all of your information, you didn’t share it with anyone.

So my leader kept me firmly in my place. She did not teach me anything about how she did her job, about anything that would help me to learn and grow and become a better, more equipped, leader.

I realised, of course, that what she was doing wasn’t leading at all. She was directing, and she was dictating.

That is not how you grow leaders.

Why did she operate like that?

I believe it was based on the experience that she had. She didn’t get mentored by her leader. She had to claw her way to the top. And that’s how she thought it had to happen for everyone. There was no sharing of knowledge. There was no collaboration. There was no supporting. There was no mentoring, guiding, challenging, encouraging, leveraging strengths. None of that. It was all about ‘you make it on your own, or you don’t make it’, as a leader.

I don’t believe that’s leadership in action.

Sadly, this is an experience that I still hear about all too often. I hear about leaders who hold onto their knowledge. I hear about leaders who don’t spend time with their people, who don’t give them opportunities to learn and to grow, who don’t share their wisdom. They just leave people to flounder, and to try and figure it out on their own. And for me, again, that’s not leadership.

Even worse, it’s a cycle that perpetuates.

Leaders create more leaders, except they don’t.

Why not?

1. Firstly, there are senior and experienced leaders today who have moved into their roles by sheer force of will, by perseverance, by luck. It’s not because their leaders showed them how. It’s not because their leaders invested time with them. They simply made their own mistakes and eventually they figured out something that worked for them.


One of the great things that is lacking in most of our companies is that they are not teaching us how to lead. Managers must go through a transition—from being responsible for the job, to being responsible for the people who are responsible for the job.

Simon Sinek


2.  Secondly, because nobody showed them how, it doesn’t necessarily occur to these leaders to be proactive when developing their people into future leaders. Yes, they ‘support’ them, but they don’t go out of their way. They don’t demonstrate enough deliberate, proactivity in developing their future leaders.

I remember my Dad telling me that the primary thing a leader must do is make time for their people.


If you want leadership to thrive and you want the people around you to become even better leaders, then you need to proactively mentor, model and coach every day. Know Leadership, Show Leadership and Grow leadership.

3. The third reason why leaders are not creating more leaders is that they haven’t been given the skills. The additional learning, the extra tools in their tool kit, to be able to mentor, model and coach. If you’re not equipped with the skills, how can you effectively be developing and creating more leaders?

Research by WorkHuman showed that 93% of the leaders who thought they were using a coaching approach, weren’t. And HBR cites a study of almost 4000 executives where 24% rated themselves as above average coaches, whereas their colleagues rated them in the bottom third.

Leaders need help to build their understanding of what coaching, and a coaching approach is. And then they need help to develop the skills so they can apply a coaching approach when working with their people.

Organisations are not only not equipping their leaders to lead, they’re not equipping their leaders to develop future leaders.

There has to be a better way. Where it’s easier to become a leader. Where we grow our leaders. Where we make the world a better place because we invest in our future, and the future of other leaders so that they then, in turn, can do exactly the same thing.

If you are a leader this is your responsibility.

So tell me, what will you do?

Leaders create more leaders.

Love to know your thoughts.

#1000leaders #thecoachingleader #leadershipcoach #executivecoach #leadership #leaderascoach #thenewleader #selfleadership #selfcoaching #firstleadyourself #linkedintopvoices #staceyashley #ashleycoaching #amazonbestseller #speaker #author #leadershipdevelopment


AND: Whenever you’re ready… here are 4 ways I can help you grow your coaching and leadership: